2013 Worlds: The Undecided

And here are those for whom we could argue it either way:

1. McKayla Maroney

On the one hand, she joins an elite band of reigning Olympic champions to return to top level gymnastics, and another elite band of WAGs to win back to back world vault titles. Those are both immense achievements, never to be undersold, but even more so in the context of her disappointment in London and the injuries she’s had to deal with.

On the other hand, though, she wasn’t particularly brilliant in Antwerp. Of the four routines she did, only her prelims bars set really represented what she’s capable of. And it’s not like that was a particularly important routine for her. Beam is and was irrelevant, but it matters a lot that she didn’t make floor finals. It is undignified indeed to get 2 per’d out by Kyla and her double tuck. That tumbling was too easy when Boginskaya did it 20 years ago. And she didn’t really nail her vaults either. There ought to have been more daylight between her and Biles (who to be fair to her was excellent).

In the end though, it just looks a bit ominous. Maroney finished the competition as the same thing she’s been for the past 3 seasons: a superb one eventer who has yet to make herself essential on any other event. That schtick would be fine on bars and probably even beam, but of course the US have incredible strength and depth on vault even without her. If Biles gets the Cheng, and to be honest it may be more of a when, Maroney’s position becomes precarious. Now I don’t think the US have enough depth for anyone to oust her in 2014. But she can’t go on like this forever…

 

2. Sandra Izbasa

Ok, she fell on her arse, but nobody gave a tiny fuck. Listen to the crowd reaction if you don’t believe me.

A star is a star is a star. That ovation was richly deserved, and is the suitable way to greet a double Olympic champion. It’s like, when Ryan Giggs finally retires, even if he misses an open net during his final game he’s still going on a lap of honour at the end. This is the same principle.

As with Aliya’s 2011 season ending fall, I think she just cracked under the sheer weight of the makeup. Personally, I’d like to see one or both of them take it to the next level and rock the corpsepaint. Why not?

Still, it takes more than yet another thrown away world title and some extremely poor cosmetics choices to undo legend status. Especially when you can perform like that. Let us just hope she was full of shit when she said it would be her farewell performance.

 

3. Team GB

As was to be expected, the guys did decently. They still haven’t managed a world title, but it surely can’t be long yet, and they look to be in a strong position to challenge for European and world team medals in 2014. They also weren’t too lucky with the judging: I am far from being the only observer who felt that Kristian Thomas could as easily have got silver as bronze (incidentally, Theo Segar was looking pretty silly after that one…).

For the women, though, it’s harder to say.

There was a famous first, in that they’d never before managed to qualify 2 gymnasts to the same global EF. Plenty at Euros, of course, but not at worlds before this, or the Olympics either. So this was some achievement, without Tweddle there.

But then Downie, with stunning predictability, threw away the team’s only real medal chance. This is a recurring theme with her. With that in mind, it’s rather hard to see where the team’s next medal is going to come from, at least until the Rio lot turn senior. At this point, Italy look to be in a much better position to challenge for the team bronze at Euros. If they’re not busy with some much needed Africana Studies classes, anyway.

 

4. Mother Russia

A tough one, this. Yet again, it’s the story of badly timed injuries, the rest underperforming and Aliya saving their bacon. A truly ridiculous situation, yet somehow they ended up second in the medal table despite not even getting a full team out in the end.

And of course it was entirely fitting that Nabieva delivered what turned out to be her swansong with a hickey on her head.

We will love her for always.

Meanwhile the Rodionenkos will continue grinding that programme down for the whole quad, pushing out talent, failing to keep stars healthy, and riding Mustafina’s uncanny ability to pull it out of the bag in the most difficult of circumstances, until she single-handedly grinds out a team bronze in Rio and they blame her for it anyway.

Stoi! readers, please do continue giving us your picks. Try and avoid complaining about the swearing, though, it’s getting very fucking old extremely fucking quickly.

By Clara


9 responses to “2013 Worlds: The Undecided

  • M

    Pretty much agree with that, esp Russia. I don’t know what they are going to do when Aliya retires, if they don’t get their shit together.

  • sainabou nyang

    Will you do a write up on Russians new seniors?

    Regarding ine country dominating a quad or meet, I don’t mind it as long as the win was based on a team being prepared and hitting their routines with very little mistakes. I may not like a certain gymnasts gymnastics but if they did their jobs and hit their routines while others fucked up they deserve their win.

    On Mustafina I’m a little worried that she wont last until Rio. I hope im wrong but I wonder about her endurance.

  • Stoi!

    Jack, we didn’t say Sandra’s make up undermines her legendary status, we said the opposite! Like your use of the word ‘cement’ there, btw. A deliberate pun?

    No idea re upgrades Zelda, though I don’t share your assessment of McKayla’s half on technique. The raw talent is certainly there, but she seems pretty physically fragile. Actually I think maybe Biles is the better bet for an upgrade. Even if it’s only the second vault- surely she’s not going to stick with that Lopez forever? She has sooo much room.

    C

  • Zelda

    Do you think that McKayla can upgrade her vaults? Both her vaults aren’t quite as high or clean as they used to be, and her half-on technique is extremely wonky, crooked and off to the side. I guess a TTY is possible, but I don’t know about the Cheng. I think her floor scored so low because her turning leaps have gotten really bad lately.

    I agree with all the other points, the one about the Rottenenkos especially, and I really hope Sandra sticks around and fixes that last pass. A back 2.5-front full is really too hard for a dismount, considering that other gymnasts (including Mustafina and Maroney) do it for their second pass, and she keeps on crashing it. Are you planning to write a tribute to Nabs’ career?

  • Jack

    I’m forced to disagree with you about Sandra’s cosmetic choices undoing her legend status. They most certainly cement it. Long live the queen!

  • emmasrandomthoughts

    I think Russia’s future is questionable at best, especially considering that the Rodionenkos seem determined to destroy the team.

    And I agree completely on Maroney. It broke my heart that she didn’t make floor finals. I know she’s working on a Cheng and a TTY, but I don’t think she can survive the new quad unless she has an additional event to offer team USA.

  • Stoi!

    I don’t mind American domination per se, it depends on the athletes. Would’ve been quite happy to see Maroney bag a hatful of medals! Even Biles, who isn’t really the artistry type, is a stunningly good vaulter and tumbler- while I wasn’t keen on her as a floor winner, I’m quite happy for difficulty like that to get a minor medal.

    Regarding Izbasa, it occurred to me the other day that she’s never actually lost a floor final when she’s hit. Incredible stat, although admittedly one that says as much about her inconsistency as anything else. Yes, it would’ve been a damn shame for Iordache to leave with nothing, but then she needs to connect with her Romanian heritage and stay on the sodding beam.
    C

  • Alia

    My Undecided pick goes to the whole Antwerp competition. The promised artistry is not there, and if it is, it gets screwed by the judges or screws itself nicely. I got so bored with all this American domination that I started watching figure skating instead. And boy, the men japanese team CAN deliver. Daisuki Takahashi is my new Afanasyeva, that’s all I have to say. Watching Hanyu makes me question my devotion to gymnastics – how is it even possible for a boy to be better in girly dances than all the elite gymnasts are. I mean, doesn’t gymnastics have the same problem as skating? Do hard tricks or go home?

  • bendyclaire

    Ha! Glad I’m not the only one who remembered Theo Seager’s ill-advised and swiftly deleted tantrum tweet when Thomas finally got his much deserved, long overdue individual medal. I unfollowed him immediately after. It was always a stupid thing to do, Thomas is an established vault star and, injuries permitting, was always going to be a medal prospect on vault…

    Agree totally re the lovely Sandra Izbasa too. Really hope she either makes a comeback in time for rio, or just has a little break for now and doesn’t retire at all. The one consolation over her fall was that it meant Iordache still got a medal she’d have otherwise missed. I couldn’t have coped with her leaving empty handed….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: