2009-2012: Clara’s Quad In Review Awards

As we stand on the cusp of a whole new quad, complete with shiny new code and the prospect of a fabulous Olympics in Rio to put the icing on the cake, it’s time to reflect on what was served up in the previous four years. It is, of course, awards season, or it was when I started work on this piece anyway. So in true Stoi! style we once again give out the gongs. Mostly by Clara, with a couple of guest appearances from Bronwyn.

Best team final

2010 Euros. I was there. It had everything. Mother Russia grabbing their first team title in a decade alone would’ve been enough.


But then the high drama of GB getting silver (and with a 3 for 3 beam rotation in the absence of the only two acceptable beamers they’ve actually had this quad, no less) and getting to witness a trademark Ukrainian meltdown in person sealed the deal. I even saw Ariella Kaeslin in the pub afterwards. The only bad part was poor Ana Porgras getting injured.

I suspect Bronners would go for 2010 worlds. And to be fair, it was the most exciting by a long way. It was very kind of Mother Russia to throw away their 2 fall advantage in the interests of a good, close competition.

Best AA

Rotterdam. Was I ever going to say anything else?

True, the Olympic AA podium was full of win: one that comprised Douglas, Komova and Mustafina in any order could not be otherwise. But it wasn’t quite up there with seeing our girl eviscerate the competition. Also, I wasn’t in labour during 2010 worlds.

Bronwyn – It’s a draw between 2010 Worlds and London for me.

Best vault final

Clara- 2011 worlds, narrowly beating 2009 for me. 2010 had a pretty top notch podium, but the shonky judging left a bad taste in the mouth. Judges ignoring FIG directives about how to tariff vaults is not ok, and nor was failing to downgrade Mustafina’s short Amanar. 2009 worlds was a lot of fun to watch, especially with all three athletes taking their first and, as it turned out, only major medals. However, any podium containing Maroney is better than one that doesn’t.

(except the Olympics, obviously. that one was a shitshow).

Best bars final

While we’ve had some excellent bars champions this quad, we’ve not had a top notch final. Can’t argue with a winners list that reads He Kexin- Tweddle- Komova- Mustafina. Each was the dog’s bollocks, in her own way, and they all won with superb sets too. No fluking it or being the best of a bad bunch. The rest of the field in 2009 was piss poor, but this was back when He Kexin was still pre-pubescent and she’d have beaten them all even if they’d hit.

Still though, it’s a shame there was never a competition where they all hit simultaneously. The Olympic was the closest, but I’m going instead for 2010 worlds. He Kexin got what she had coming, Beth and Aliya were as good a 1-2 as anyone could hope for. Runner up- 2012 Euros with the all ex-Soviet podium. It’s a little known fact that Chusovitina actually gave birth to all three of the medallists.

Best beam final

The only one this quad that has been even close to acceptable is 2010 worlds. I refuse to speak of any other.

Best floor final

As with beam, we’ve hardly been spoiled for choice. Of the four major titles this quad, only one of them has been won by a routine that wasn’t disgusting. True, Afanasyeva arguably makes up for a large portion of the horror. But even her triumph occurred in the context of a final that featured far too much gymnastic lochea.

Euros weren’t much better, especially at first. We love Tweddle, oh yes we do, but not when she dances. Fortunately, the girls from Deva saved us mid-quad: Izbasa’s 2011 win represents the only time all quad that she didn’t fail us. Lauren Mitchell world champion is Sandra’s fucking fault. We can’t blame Afan, she’d already done her hit routine for the championship. She has a quota and it had been all used up.

So, Tokyo worlds it is then. Sui Lu slayed!

Best performance by a coffin dodger

As we tiptoed into the quad with Beijing still ringing in our eyes, all the talk was of youngsters. Specifically, the 14 and 15 year olds that Team China pretended were legally aged and the shitstorm that erupted when the world cottoned on. This time round, however, the more notable performances have come from the other end of the spectrum. The Chinese appear to have dialled down the infants for this quad, although Yao Jinnan has raised a few eyebrows, and the old bitches have taken centre stage instead. Deng Linlin looked increasingly like an old man as the quad progressed, so we did consider her, but reluctantly decided that athletes should really have to be at least mid 20s to qualify.

Ultimately, it has to be a tie between Chusovitina and Tweddle- both of whom I confidently expect to see in Rio. Oksana will now be competing for Uzbekistan again, and about their only advantage over Germany is the lesser competition for the team. And Beth has pointedly referred to herself recently as a gymnast who hasn’t yet retired. Chussy is older, but Tweddle had the better quad, so we can’t bring ourselves to separate them. We’d give an honourable mention to the Brazilians, several of whom are 30 or getting there, if any of them had done anything worth seeing recently. They haven’t so we won’t. You have to do more than be old to win in this category.

Worst team selection

GB in London, naturellement. Regular readers will have heard all about my feelings on this one. Neither Cairns nor Pinches had any business anywhere near that team. And then BG had the gall to pretend that 6th place represented some kind of success!

Sweetest justice

Team Ukraine finally getting the 1999 world team bronze medal that was stolen from them by China cheating. There are still a few more where that came from, ask Anastasia Koval, but this is something. For me, it beats the US getting the Sydney bronze, as Ukraine need it so much more.

Photo courtesy of Irina Krasnyanska & Kyan

Honourable mention for reference panel stepping in to stop Raisman winning floor gold in 2010. Justified and righteous.

Most irritating commentary

Anything by Matt Baker. It boils my piss that he occupies St Barry’s seat. If it weren’t for Dr Who, I’d withhold the licence fee in protest.

Bronwyn- NBC character assassination of Aliya at Scam 2011. Just fuck off.

Scammiest Scam

Clara- 2012. The ludicrousness of the hors concours athlete kicking the winner’s are rightly got most of the attention, but Iordache being done out of her silver was the bigger iniquity from where I was sitting.

Bronwyn- Jordyn getting 15 on floor in 2011

Top comeback

Obviously Aliya. To bust your ACL 16 months before the Olympics and bring home the medal haul that she did requires levels of grit not seen in the sport since the last time Memmel did a crucial routine for Team USA with a limb hanging off. In a way, it all worked out for the best.

Stoi! readers, do let us know your picks.


7 responses to “2009-2012: Clara’s Quad In Review Awards

  • 1989ymdancer


    Best team competition: Russia 2010
    Best AA: Aliya Mustafina 2010
    Best Vault final: 2011
    Best Bars final: 2012
    Best Beam final: either 2010 or 2011
    Best Floor final: 2011
    Coffin dodger: Beth Tweddle olympic prelims bars/Oksana Chusovitina
    Team selection: Not exactly a team, but team USA 2011 running out of able-bodied gymnasts and bad alternate choices
    Justice: Can’t really think of one
    Bad Commentary: Anything Tim, Al, and Elfie have ever said
    Scam: Didn’t watch it
    Comeback: Aliya, obviously

  • Alfi

    Best Team final = 2010 Worlds/ Euros, Best AA = 2010 Worlds, Best Vault final = any final that didnt include Amanar disease, Best Beam final= Euros 2010, Best UB final = Olympics, Best floor final = Worlds 2010. Coffin dodger = Chuso straight away. Sweetest justice hmm =, Komova Wieber. AA 2011 vs AA London 2012. Irritating commentary= the 3 NBC monkies. Scamiest Scam = Raisman’s 15.600 FX final in London. Top comeback = Aliya.

    I would also add the best floor music and that goes for Aliya 2010 & 2011

  • gem

    you two are the best. as is your ‘best performance by a coffin dodger’ category. i love you for noticing deng linlin’s transformation into a pensioner (seriously thought it was only me who saw that) but come on, no mention of ponor? she’s the vampire i never knew i wanted in my life.

    and i’m gonna be honest worlds 2010 was the best thing this quad for me. russia trying and failing to throw away a massive lead (aliya obv. didnt get the memo here), it being aliya’s ‘fuck you all, here i am’ arrival party, tanya nabieva’s facial expressions (need their own award), afan fucking up individual finals, and kurbatova looking genuinely like she didnt know why she was there for the whole thing.

    oh, memories.

  • Stoi!

    NBC are lavishly moronic. Fire them, and bring in Miller.

  • M

    That was hilarious to read especially about the Olympics vault final being “piss poor” and about you would have mentioned Brazilians if they had done something, lol.

    My picks are similar to yours.

    Best Team Final – tie between 2010 Euros and 2010 Worlds for me. I was happy for Russia finally winning Euros, and you could see Aliya worked her tail off for the team. Same could be said for 2010 worlds, while the teammates were falling off bars as if their hand had on oil or something, she stepped up, granted she fell on her floor performance. 2010 worlds was exciting because you didn’t know who might win since Russia had the falls, and at the last apparatus, US on Vault vs Russia on Floor.

    Best AA – same answer for me, 2010 Worlds

    Best Vault Final – Not sure, I don’t remember watching many vault finals.

    Best Beam – Agreed, the only one where I didn’t have to see people falling left, right and center – 2010 worlds.

    Best Floor – didn’t really watch it a lot but I liked 2010 worlds again

    Best Bars Final – Olympics. No one fell off! There were couple problems, mainly Komova and Douglas, but for the most part, it was a solid and great event.

    Best Performance by Coffin person – I don’t know many of the old ones, so I guess if we are doing your age thing, Tweddle could be an option. I like Izbasa, but I just realized she is 22, she just looks old. However for me, it is Ponor for best performance.

    Team Selection – didn’t pay attention to it, so don’t care.

    Scammiest Scam – Only watched one, so can’t comment.

    Irritating Commentary – Anything those 3 idiots on NBC say. I don’t know but they seem to still think a cold war is going on, because they were horrible at Scam about Aliya and you would think they would change by Olympics, but nope got even worse….disgusting. Also just them commenting on anyone really.

    Top Comeback – Definitely Aliya, she is a fighter/trooper, to come back and do what she did was pretty awesome to see.

    I have another heading:

    Most enjoyable year of the Quad – For me 2010 was a pretty cool year where people performed great and I enjoyed that year. Olympics would be number 2….at least the parts where people actually didn’t fall off.

    I enjoyed the Olympics Men’s Vault Final (take note women) and the High Bar Final.

  • Stoi!

    Izbasa isn’t quite old enough to qualify. Really you need to be at least 24. I’d possibly accept an unusually creaky 23 year old.

  • Julia

    Surprised not to see Catalina Ponor and Sandra Izbasa in the “Best performance by a coffin dodger” category. Romania wouldn’t have had a snowball’s chance in hell for an Olympic team medal without their performances, especially not after Iordache’s injury.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: